Episode Review #1: Father's Day, and Doctor Who's Paradox Problem

Hey, everyone!

My name's Barry and I'm currently on my first binge-watch of Doctor Who (2005), up to Season 10. Once I finish the Moffat era, I'll make a couple posts documenting some of my more longform thoughts on the series as a whole, (since the Chibnall/Whittaker era is still going so it feels weirder to comment on those,) but for now, there are a few episodes that I have much more nuanced thoughts on. Episodes that I think wouldn't fit into the posts that I'm planning, since I have too much to say.

The first one of these is Father's Day, the eighth episode of the first season, written by Paul Cornell (known for The Family of Blood) and starring Christopher Eccleston as the Ninth Doctor.

Some of my favorite episodes tend to be really good character episodes, where characterization is the main focus, with adequate to excellent science fiction in the background or as the framing device. Take, for instance, A Christmas Carol, which is entirely dedicated to focusing on the villain and his motivation, with the audience's sympathy (ideally) being built up over the course of the episode until we've seen enough of his life to fully understand him emotionally, and be invested in his character growth. Really good character episode, with adequate science fiction that takes a background role.

Father's Day, comparatively, is a brilliant character episode... with really crappy science fiction.

The episode begins with a flashback to when Rose was a child and Jackie (her mother) showing her a photobook of her father, Pete, played by Shaun Dingwall, and explaining how good of a man he was, and his untimely death at the hands of a car. Jackie explains how no one was there for him when he died, he was just alone, on the street, bleeding out.

We then see present-day Rose, presumably having explained all of this to the Doctor, asking if she can go to that day, the 7th of November 1987, and be with him as he dies.

The Doctor agrees, saying "your wish is my command" and giving Rose a sense of autonomy. However, when the moment comes and Pete Tyler gets struck by the car, now with Rose there to see it in-person, she freezes, and then runs away, ashamed that she wasn't able to be there for him, and we see her ask if she can try again. Then, we see that, while the Doctor and Rose were standing there frozen, the future Doctor and Rose were just behind them, waiting to give Rose a second chance once they left... but Rose runs out, saves Pete's life, and the first

... keep reading on reddit ➑

πŸ‘︎ 20
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/drspookulicious
πŸ“…︎ Oct 24 2021
🚨︎ report
SERIOUS: This subreddit needs to understand what a "dad joke" really means.

I don't want to step on anybody's toes here, but the amount of non-dad jokes here in this subreddit really annoys me. First of all, dad jokes CAN be NSFW, it clearly says so in the sub rules. Secondly, it doesn't automatically make it a dad joke if it's from a conversation between you and your child. Most importantly, the jokes that your CHILDREN tell YOU are not dad jokes. The point of a dad joke is that it's so cheesy only a dad who's trying to be funny would make such a joke. That's it. They are stupid plays on words, lame puns and so on. There has to be a clever pun or wordplay for it to be considered a dad joke.

Again, to all the fellow dads, I apologise if I'm sounding too harsh. But I just needed to get it off my chest.

πŸ‘︎ 16k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/anywhereiroa
πŸ“…︎ Jan 15 2022
🚨︎ report
Completing the Matrix: August 2006 Production Notes Extra for Doctor Who Magazine #373: Companion Piece - Russell T Davies gives DWM readers an exclusive account of the recent comings and goings aboard the TARDIS...

This was written by Russell T Davies and it was from after Doomsday and before The Runaway Bride were broadcast, and the issue looked back on the Series Two finale, Doomsday. The latest issue of Doctor Who Magazine, which interviews cast members from Series 13, is on sale now.

Want an archive of the previous Production Notes that have been posted on /r/gallifrey?: Follow this link or this one.


##Companion Piece

Right from the start of Series Two, we knew that we had to write out Rose Tyler, and introduce a new companion - to use that opportunity to show the new audience the full, proper format of Doctor Who, first established way back in The Dalek Invasion of Earth, when the Doctor's granddaughter, Susan, left the crew; that life changes, the TARDIS changes, that the Doctor remains constant while his fellow travellers come and go.

To be honest, writing out Rose was the easy bit! Yes, we're so sad to see Billie go, but at the same time, there's an excitement about change. For Billie and for us. I'd known from the very start of Series One how to separate the two time-travellers, stranded in two separate universes, and with the contracts for Camille, Noel and Shaun Dingwall locked into place for Series Two... well, all we had to do was write it!

But the new companion? My immediate decision was that there would be two. A one-off Bride, to really hammer home the coming-and-going notion, and to take the curse off the tag of 'the New Girl', and then a proper, full-time replacement, to launch Series Three. That's the fiction side of it, but on the production side, there was another dictate - to cast a Great Big Talented Name as the Bride, to draw people both into Christmas, and into the 'new' format. And then, to replace Billie with... well, a complete unknown. (Terrible phrase, 'unknown', I'm deliberately using industry-speak - Freema's done all sorts of work in many different shows, and there must be lots of people who know her very well!) All of us, all the way up to Jane Tranter, instinctively said the same thing: it's got to be someone new. Billie Pipers are rare, if not unique, and any other young actor with a bit of a profile would have seemed, well, a bit Second Hand Rose. And besides, it's part of our job to discover new talent. The role of the Doctor's new companion could give someone a massive,

... keep reading on reddit ➑

πŸ‘︎ 37
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ“…︎ Oct 06 2021
🚨︎ report
Blind Girl Here. Give Me Your Best Blind Jokes!

Do your worst!

πŸ‘︎ 5k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/Leckzsluthor
πŸ“…︎ Jan 02 2022
🚨︎ report
This subreddit is 10 years old now.

I'm surprised it hasn't decade.

πŸ‘︎ 14k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/frexyincdude
πŸ“…︎ Jan 14 2022
🚨︎ report
Dropped my best ever dad joke & no one was around to hear it

For context I'm a Refuse Driver (Garbage man) & today I was on food waste. After I'd tipped I was checking the wagon for any defects when I spotted a lone pea balanced on the lifts.

I said "hey look, an escaPEA"

No one near me but it didn't half make me laugh for a good hour or so!

Edit: I can't believe how much this has blown up. Thank you everyone I've had a blast reading through the replies πŸ˜‚

πŸ‘︎ 19k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/Vegetable-Acadia
πŸ“…︎ Jan 11 2022
🚨︎ report
What starts with a W and ends with a T

It really does, I swear!

πŸ‘︎ 6k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/PsychedeIic_Sheep
πŸ“…︎ Jan 13 2022
🚨︎ report
What is a a bisexual person doing when they’re not dating anybody?

They’re on standbi

πŸ‘︎ 11k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/Toby-the-Cactus
πŸ“…︎ Jan 12 2022
🚨︎ report
What do you call quesadillas you eat in the morning?

Buenosdillas

πŸ‘︎ 12k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/FarronKeepSucks
πŸ“…︎ Jan 14 2022
🚨︎ report
Geddit? No? Only me?
πŸ‘︎ 6k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/shampy311
πŸ“…︎ Dec 28 2021
🚨︎ report
I wanna hear your best airplane puns.

Pilot on me!!

πŸ‘︎ 3k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/Paulie_Felice
πŸ“…︎ Jan 07 2022
🚨︎ report
E or ß?
πŸ‘︎ 9k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/Amazekam
πŸ“…︎ Jan 03 2022
🚨︎ report
No spoilers
πŸ‘︎ 9k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/Onfour
πŸ“…︎ Jan 06 2022
🚨︎ report
Covid problems
πŸ‘︎ 7k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/theincrediblebou
πŸ“…︎ Jan 12 2022
🚨︎ report
These aren't dad jokes...

Dad jokes are supposed to be jokes you can tell a kid and they will understand it and find it funny.

This sub is mostly just NSFW puns now.

If it needs a NSFW tag it's not a dad joke. There should just be a NSFW puns subreddit for that.

Edit* I'm not replying any longer and turning off notifications but to all those that say "no one cares", there sure are a lot of you arguing about it. Maybe I'm wrong but you people don't need to be rude about it. If you really don't care, don't comment.

πŸ‘︎ 12k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/Lance986
πŸ“…︎ Dec 15 2021
🚨︎ report
I had a vasectomy because I didn’t want any kids.

When I got home, they were still there.

πŸ‘︎ 10k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/demotrek
πŸ“…︎ Jan 13 2022
🚨︎ report
What did 0 say to 8 ?

What did 0 say to 8 ?

" Nice Belt "

So What did 3 say to 8 ?

" Hey, you two stop making out "

πŸ‘︎ 9k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/designjeevan
πŸ“…︎ Jan 03 2022
🚨︎ report
Spi__
πŸ‘︎ 6k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/Fast_Echidna_8520
πŸ“…︎ Jan 11 2022
🚨︎ report
I dislike karma whores who make posts that imply it's their cake day, simply for upvotes.

I won't be doing that today!

πŸ‘︎ 15k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/djcarves
πŸ“…︎ Dec 27 2021
🚨︎ report
The Ancient Romans II
πŸ‘︎ 6k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/mordrathe
πŸ“…︎ Dec 29 2021
🚨︎ report
I'd like to dedicate this joke to my wisdom teeth.

[Removed]

πŸ‘︎ 7k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/ThoughtPumP
πŸ“…︎ Jan 14 2022
🚨︎ report
How do you stop Canadian bacon from curling in your frying pan?

You take away their little brooms

πŸ‘︎ 6k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/Majorpain2006
πŸ“…︎ Jan 09 2022
🚨︎ report
I did it, I finally did it. After 4 years and 92 days I went from being a father, to a dad.

This morning, my 4 year old daughter.

Daughter: I'm hungry

Me: nerves building, smile widening

Me: Hi hungry, I'm dad.

She had no idea what was going on but I finally did it.

Thank you all for listening.

πŸ‘︎ 17k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/Sk2ec
πŸ“…︎ Jan 01 2022
🚨︎ report
Pun intended.
πŸ‘︎ 4k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/Sharmaji1301
πŸ“…︎ Jan 15 2022
🚨︎ report
It this sub dead?

There hasn't been a post all year!

πŸ‘︎ 13k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/TheTreelo
πŸ“…︎ Jan 01 2022
🚨︎ report
School Was Clothed
πŸ‘︎ 5k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/Kennydoe
πŸ“…︎ Jan 08 2022
🚨︎ report
Letting loose with these puns
πŸ‘︎ 6k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ“…︎ Jan 13 2022
🚨︎ report
Couch potato
πŸ‘︎ 8k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ“…︎ Dec 31 2021
🚨︎ report
Baka!
πŸ‘︎ 5k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/ridi86
πŸ“…︎ Jan 09 2022
🚨︎ report
All dad jokes are bad and here’s why

Why

πŸ‘︎ 7k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/LordCinko
πŸ“…︎ Jan 13 2022
🚨︎ report
concrete πŸ—Ώ
πŸ‘︎ 5k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/Fast_Echidna_8520
πŸ“…︎ Jan 07 2022
🚨︎ report
My name is ABCDEFGHIJKMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ

It’s pronounced β€œNoel.”

πŸ‘︎ 14k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/beef_fried_rice
πŸ“…︎ Dec 25 2021
🚨︎ report
Why are people so surprised and angry about Djokovic being an anti-vaxxer?

After all his first name is No-vac

πŸ‘︎ 4k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/hangryman23
πŸ“…︎ Jan 06 2022
🚨︎ report
What did Spartacus say when the lion ate his wife?

Nothing, he was gladiator.

πŸ‘︎ 5k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/rj104
πŸ“…︎ Jan 15 2022
🚨︎ report
If Korean pop is shortened to Kpop and Korean Drama is Kdrama...

What, then, is Chinese rap?

Edit:

Notable mentions from the comments:

  • Spanish/Swedish/Swiss/Serbian hits

  • French/Finnish art

  • Country/Canadian rap

  • Chinese/Country/Canadian rock

  • Turkish/Tunisian/Taiwanese rap

πŸ‘︎ 3k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/hootanahalf
πŸ“…︎ Jan 09 2022
🚨︎ report
That’s Michelle
πŸ‘︎ 5k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/FLEXSEALBREAKER
πŸ“…︎ Jan 10 2022
🚨︎ report
Is this sub still active?

There hasn't been a single post this year!

(Happy 2022 from New Zealand)

πŸ‘︎ 10k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/DonStimpo
πŸ“…︎ Dec 31 2021
🚨︎ report
What did the ocean say to the beach?

Nothing, it just waved

πŸ‘︎ 2k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/hackerboi1198
πŸ“…︎ Jan 13 2022
🚨︎ report
is Isn't
πŸ‘︎ 2k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/mordrathe
πŸ“…︎ Jan 11 2022
🚨︎ report
My 9 year old son just asked me to pretend I was a police officer arresting him for downloading the entire Wikipedia. Me: Young man, you're under arrest for downloading the entire Wikipedia!

Him: I can explain everything!

(It's his best joke yet I think)

πŸ‘︎ 7k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/MrPJ2020
πŸ“…︎ Jan 14 2022
🚨︎ report
@u/mordrathe - remix
πŸ‘︎ 2k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/SpydrRydr
πŸ“…︎ Jan 12 2022
🚨︎ report
What do you call a guy with no arms and no legs in a hot tub?

Bob

πŸ‘︎ 2k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/4fuchssake
πŸ“…︎ Jan 05 2022
🚨︎ report
I named my dog "5 miles."

So that I could frequently say, "I am going to walk 5 miles now."

Edit: My most popular post on Reddit! πŸ˜€ Thank you for the awards.

πŸ‘︎ 3k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/javacafe
πŸ“…︎ Jan 10 2022
🚨︎ report
My WIFI password is 2444666668888888

Just to clarify, 12345678

πŸ‘︎ 6k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/az1m_
πŸ“…︎ Jan 03 2022
🚨︎ report
Possibly the greatest Snap Reaction dad joke I've ever told (it even got me a POWERFUL groan and vehement FU from my wife)

Me grabbing a soda from my (what I thought was) half full 12pk...

Notices there's only 2;

Me: "Awe man... This is a damn bird box!" Her: "What the hell does that mean?!" Me: (Pulls both cans out & shows them to her) "It's only got Toucans."

I'm not ashamed to admit the look on her face was glorious.

πŸ‘︎ 6k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/AKhakiNerfHerder
πŸ“…︎ Jan 10 2022
🚨︎ report
I can't believe I was arrested for impersonating a politician...

I was just sitting there doing nothing.

πŸ‘︎ 9k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/ENJOYblet
πŸ“…︎ Jan 05 2022
🚨︎ report
Guns
πŸ‘︎ 4k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/PlayYo-KaiWatch21
πŸ“…︎ Jan 10 2022
🚨︎ report
The two genders
πŸ‘︎ 8k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/ShrimpRex
πŸ“…︎ Dec 27 2021
🚨︎ report
If β€œwomb” is pronounced β€œwoom” and β€œtomb” is pronounced β€œtoom” then shouldn’t β€œbomb” be pronounced…

β€œBOOM”?!

πŸ‘︎ 9k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/FourBloodMoons
πŸ“…︎ Dec 24 2021
🚨︎ report

Please note that this site uses cookies to personalise content and adverts, to provide social media features, and to analyse web traffic. Click here for more information.