Opinion: Why Hermoine's S.P.E.W. is wrong, even with the best of intentions.

Before I go into this, let's start on common ground we can agree on: Hagrid is not evil. Agreed? If not you can fuck right off.

Hagrid may have a slight problem of overtrusting, but at the end of the day you can't exactly look at this Scottish Steve-Irwrin-Santa and think he's some mad slaver, so when he tells Hermoine in The Goblet of Fire β€˜It’s in their nature ter look after humans, that’s what they like, see? Yeh’d be makin’ ’em unhappy ter take away their work, an’ insultin’ ’em if yeh tried ter pay ’em.’, you have to take a second to realize what he means.

House Elves are simply criminally underrated in the realm of fantasy novels. To take a children's series, and as early as book two illustrate to kids geopolitical and historical issues in a digestible way, as well as avoid the easy route of making your fantasy world just cotton candy escapism and instead illustrate true issues within the world, is simply brilliant.

The two house elves we become closest with, Dobby and Kreacher, are set up polar opposites; the traditionally grumpy and downright cruel, and the buoyant and merry. What's interesting though isn't how they're different, but how wildly similar they are in many regards. Aside from simply both coming from a background of dark wizarding families, both go on to not just serve, but to aid (crucial difference) Harry, Ron, and Hermoine after being shown even the smallest drop of affection, further illustrating JK Rowling's throughline in her work that every being, no matter how 'foul' or outcasted, is deserving of love, and that beautiful things can happen when you give someone the respect they need. This happened to Kreacher in one of the more overlooked yet touching character arcs, who was put through an absolute emotional and mental meat grinder of an existence, living surrounding by the severed heads of his family and kind, only to revert so dramatically he will literally die to defend the values of those who showed him kindness. "For Master Regulus!" he bellows, as he leads the house elves to fight in the battle for Hogwarts.

House Elves do not inherently serve, they inherently aid. Like the hospice workers of the wizarding world, they subsist in making the lives of individuals just a bit easier. And this is where Hermoine is wrong for the right reasons; there's no shame whatsoever in living to aid others. While from Hermoine's raising outside the world this may be seen as servitude or slavery, she missed one key issue with S.P.E.

... keep reading on reddit ➑

πŸ‘︎ 5k
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/YourDailyDevil
πŸ“…︎ Oct 17 2018
🚨︎ report
[Baker Mayfield] My intentions were not to throw our medical staff under the bus. No I don’t know all the facts about Odell’s injury. It was emotionally answered because I can sense his frustration and I care about my team and putting us in the best position to win. twitter.com/bakermayfield…
πŸ‘︎ 219
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/Notpurple243
πŸ“…︎ Dec 08 2019
🚨︎ report
[Vacchiano] A hint, perhaps, from Jets GM Joe Douglas about his intentions early in the NFL Draft?: "I think there’s a real shortage of quality offensive linemen in the NFL, so we’re going to do our best to get as many quality ones as we can because you can never have too many." twitter.com/RVacchianoSNY…
πŸ‘︎ 101
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/oman1943
πŸ“…︎ Apr 01 2020
🚨︎ report
Even with the best intentions, not everyone succeeded in not drinking yesterday. It’s ok, you are back reading this sub today and it’s a new day!
πŸ‘︎ 485
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/Cinderella96761
πŸ“…︎ Nov 29 2019
🚨︎ report
β€˜I like oil!’ Trump reaffirms predatory intentions in Syria as Assad calls him β€˜the best’ US president for his honesty rt.com/news/472492-best-p…
πŸ‘︎ 237
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/ecipch
πŸ“…︎ Nov 03 2019
🚨︎ report
Hunt has sent this letter to EU foreign minister. First, am sure it wasn’t the intention, but it comes across as the β€˜dear Europeans, let me explain things to you because Britain knows best’ that so annoys many member states (beyond Brexit). twitter.com/AlbertoNardel…
πŸ‘︎ 85
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/bottish
πŸ“…︎ Oct 10 2019
🚨︎ report
My best intentions go all to hell, something about the GRAV that I just can’t resist it! I’m going to divest myself of all smoking accessories so I quit combusting once and for all, edibles and an occasional vape sesh with an ultimate goal of using edibles and tinctures only! Gifting the GRAV plus v.redd.it/koxopxjgah441
πŸ‘︎ 74
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/Reyeuro-
πŸ“…︎ Dec 13 2019
🚨︎ report
I always start with the best intentions and this happens
πŸ‘︎ 100
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/plasticblowfish
πŸ“…︎ Feb 23 2020
🚨︎ report
If I wanted to get a little girl into a martial art, which would be the best if my intention would be giving her the ability to totally defend herself in a real life attack sort of situation? And how young can kids start?

Something she could grow into and hone over years

πŸ‘︎ 44
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/everneveragain
πŸ“…︎ Jul 28 2019
🚨︎ report
Joey is the best friend of the group. Sure he doesn’t always make the best decisions but everything he does has good intentions and he really would do anything for his friends.
πŸ‘︎ 213
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/notrelatabl
πŸ“…︎ Oct 25 2019
🚨︎ report
I start with the best intentions
πŸ‘︎ 251
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/hannah4colbert
πŸ“…︎ Sep 19 2019
🚨︎ report
Even though made with the best intentions this gave me goosebumps. [text]
πŸ‘︎ 752
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/bIondebombe
πŸ“…︎ Oct 31 2019
🚨︎ report
Jaclyn had the best intentions in the world. But this was a bad video.

I believe everything Jaclyn is saying, and it’s scary. But the only person who can help Eugenia is Eugenia. We know that she’s REALLY good at denying when she has a problem; she’s gonna do the same when it comes to her mom, especially because her mom controls everything in her life.

Jaclyn made a really bad move releasing the video; the selfish part of me likes the fact it confirms my suspicions about the Shane video and EC’s situation as a whole, but the other part of me knows this can’t go well.

Abusive relationships like EC’s are all about power and control. ECβ€˜s video with Shane was all about taking back a little bit of the power; SHE got to define herself as someone who was struggling but recovering, and SHE got to define herself as more than that.

The only thing that EC needs right now is to feel empowered. No one can remove her from her mother, because nothing her mom does is illegal. She has to make that decision herself. Jaclyn taking away her power in a video like this is really harmful to Eugenia. None of us can take Eugenia out of the situation she is in; we know because we tried that with her eating disorder. She has to come to that conclusion on her own.

πŸ‘︎ 90
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ“…︎ Jul 20 2019
🚨︎ report
Does the enemy AI really not care about clearing Maria Hill’s Best of Intentions tile?

I’m new to the game (about a month playing and I still feel like I know nothing) so I don’t know how unusual this ability is. But in Maria Hill’s event my strategy is honestly to let her match black tiles and wait for her to commit suicide. I’ve honestly seen the AI ignore matches for that countdown tile for other matches.

πŸ‘︎ 11
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/mattster42
πŸ“…︎ Mar 16 2020
🚨︎ report
What is the greatest evil that has been committed with genuinely the best intentions?
πŸ‘︎ 13
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/SomeRandomRealtor
πŸ“…︎ Aug 16 2019
🚨︎ report
Targeted with the best intentions!
πŸ‘︎ 44
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/auldnate
πŸ“…︎ Jan 27 2020
🚨︎ report
We always start with the best of intentions imgur.com/tlzvidx
πŸ‘︎ 398
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/toxik0n
πŸ“…︎ Nov 10 2019
🚨︎ report
Sovereign was perfect to the ME1 story, best of the 4! Shadowed by Saren & unknown to the galaxy to establish the story that makes the series + show the Reaper’s intentions is great! As terrifying/satisfying as a villain can be with an OST just as chilling, I loved the vanguard of our destruction!
πŸ‘︎ 274
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/Onlyhooper
πŸ“…︎ Feb 12 2019
🚨︎ report
They say that the road to evil is paved with good intentions. Historically, what has been the best example of that?
πŸ‘︎ 4
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/RikerV2
πŸ“…︎ Feb 20 2020
🚨︎ report
If a stray dog is running towards you with the obvious intention of by biting you and causing you harm, what would be the best and safest way to react?
πŸ‘︎ 3
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/VisionaryPrism
πŸ“…︎ Dec 25 2019
🚨︎ report
It’s with the best intentions
πŸ‘︎ 84
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/Rover-II
πŸ“…︎ Jan 16 2020
🚨︎ report
Sometimes the best intentions have unintended consequences

So, ever since the brainiacs at the FDA and Dexcom have made it harder to restart a sensor so that people would not go beyond the 10 day period I have noticed that instead of going 14 or 15 days on a sensor I have been going 19 or 20 days on a sensor because it is such a pain in the ass to restart a sensor now with the 8H or GH sensors. So FDA and Dexcom, if your intention was to prevent people from extending their sensors beyond 10 days it was a total fail. At least with me it’s caused me to extend even longer.

πŸ‘︎ 2
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/Rocket01887
πŸ“…︎ Mar 04 2020
🚨︎ report
Walking is our best friend. Had all the intentions of eating moderate carbs but BG at 128, not the best starting read. Decided to fast walk for 45 min to improve the numbers and earn those moderate carbs, this my fellow T2D peers is the secret to indulgences when dealing with our nasty disease.
πŸ‘︎ 37
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/nando1969
πŸ“…︎ Jul 04 2019
🚨︎ report
The Best Intentions...

Akame stood in the kitchen, pulling things out of the refrigerator and different cabinets and setting them all out on the counter. It seemed like she was preparing to cook a small feast but in truth she was just trying to get out in front of the boy’s appetites, as if Lyger wasn’t eating enough to feed several people on his own. Before long the of olive oil and seasoning began to fill the house, amidst the sound of food being chopped and meat being prepared. Before long she heard Denji on the stairs, wondering how long it would take him to join her as he often did around this time in the morning.

He yawned heavily as he entered the room, arms stretching over his head he leaned his body to either side before flopping down into a seat at the table.

D: β€œI could definitely get used to all this homecooking, my dad almost never cooks and mom’s generally already at the school before I wake up, preparing lessons for the day.”

A: β€œWell honestly, you’re lucky your father doesn’t cook, it’s awful, and I’m sure if he actually did he’d force you to eat it” she chuckled as she scooped a handful of chopped vegetables and dropped them onto the skillet.

After lingering for a moment, still waking himself up Denji eventually stood and got himself some tea, peering over her shoulder to see what she was making, β€œwhere’s Lyger” he asked as he headed back to his seat.

A: β€œI have to imagine he’s at the Akegawa’s by now, seems like he gets up earlier and earlier every morning” she sighed, her tone a bit stressed, suddenly drowned out by the loud sizzle of freshly cut meat being added to the mix.

D:” What’s wrong” he rested his chin in his hand, posting his elbow on the table for support, β€œdid something happen?”

A: β€œHe’s been acting differently lately.. Doesn’t really feel like my little boy anymore ya know” she turned to lean against the counter, shaking her head, β€œever since he found out, it just hasn’t been the same between us.”

D: β€œHow so… I mean all he did before is train, that’s pretty much all he does now right” he asked, shrugging his shoulders.

A: β€œIt’s more than that… He doesn’t really t

... keep reading on reddit ➑

πŸ‘︎ 3
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/Logickalp
πŸ“…︎ Apr 30 2019
🚨︎ report
So the David Bowie concert went well despite my best intentions. imgur.com/90aGMvR
πŸ‘︎ 58
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ“…︎ Dec 06 2019
🚨︎ report
Thought you guys might enjoy some of the great β€œmade-up-sounding” band names on this Kentish festival poster that got dropped into work, including Mr B the Gentleman Rhymer, Funke & the Two Tone Baby, and Best Intentions
πŸ‘︎ 37
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/GoblinsPalace
πŸ“…︎ Mar 28 2019
🚨︎ report
What is the best way to answer the β€œwhat are your intentions with my daughter” question?
πŸ‘︎ 3
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/Nrgy214
πŸ“…︎ Mar 10 2020
🚨︎ report
Crushed SQ: I had the best intentions and ended up being "Mr. Steal Your Boy"
πŸ‘︎ 37
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/0Graham_Cracker0
πŸ“…︎ Aug 31 2019
🚨︎ report
If everyone assumed the best intentions and good faith of everyone else, how would the world change?
πŸ‘︎ 2
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/badRLplayer
πŸ“…︎ Mar 11 2020
🚨︎ report
Being centrists means that you’re able to see that republicans and Democrats only have the best of intentions in mind.

Just because their policies may be different doesn’t mean that one side is β€œgood” and he other is β€œbad”. Being able have such a rational view of politics is what makes one a centrist. How this is hard for some people to grasp blows my mind...

πŸ‘︎ 7
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/TheSaint7
πŸ“…︎ Jan 31 2019
🚨︎ report
What’s the best movie that you’ve accidentally come across (like you had no intention of watching it but you were bored and did and you loved it)?
πŸ‘︎ 2
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/erbewhi
πŸ“…︎ Jun 05 2019
🚨︎ report
What's the best answer to when a father asks what are your intentions with his daughter?
πŸ‘︎ 2
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/parquinnien
πŸ“…︎ Aug 23 2019
🚨︎ report
Fathers of reddit, what’s the best response to β€œWhat are your intentions with my daughter/son?” You’ve gotten?
πŸ‘︎ 6
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/PertPeak
πŸ“…︎ Nov 15 2019
🚨︎ report
Can 歀致 be used at the end of a business letter, with the intention of saying something like β€œBest” or β€œBest Regards?
πŸ‘︎ 2
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/mementomoriok
πŸ“…︎ Jan 02 2020
🚨︎ report
I just dont understand the intention here. What is his best case scenario?
πŸ‘︎ 32
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/projectbadasss
πŸ“…︎ Nov 02 2018
🚨︎ report
I have the best intentions I swear
πŸ‘︎ 77
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/economonstah
πŸ“…︎ Sep 03 2019
🚨︎ report
What’s the hardest thing you’ve had to but meant it with the best intentions?
πŸ‘︎ 4
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ“…︎ Nov 09 2019
🚨︎ report
What's something your parents did with the best if intentions that just didnt quite workout to plan?
πŸ‘︎ 3
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/Thundrstrm
πŸ“…︎ May 11 2019
🚨︎ report
The Best of Intentions
πŸ‘︎ 106
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ“…︎ Jun 30 2018
🚨︎ report
When did your best intentions cause the most damage?
πŸ‘︎ 2
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/RandoBrandoBanjo
πŸ“…︎ Mar 14 2020
🚨︎ report
After five years of regular meditation, including two as a Buddhist Monk, I feel like a completely new person. I've realized five things to do every day to operate at our highest level so we can be our best self. Meditating, stretching, setting daily intention, not overeating, sleeping early.

Meditation definitely played a significant role in my life and how I've changed from being an accountant hating my job into a school teacher/ yoga instructor who also runs a learning school for kids in Thailand.

However, I must emphasize the importance the other four points played in complementing my practice. It allowed me to have a healthy, strong and energetic body to utilize and clear goals and objectives to focus on.

Its changed my life so much I made a short video about it to share as I feel it's easier to communicate good ideas through videos sometimes.

Please take a look and let me know what you think!

https://youtu.be/kTt91zDMx58

Much love and best wishes to all of you πŸ™‚β€πŸ™

πŸ‘︎ 378
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/sickient
πŸ“…︎ Feb 16 2020
🚨︎ report
[Woj] On timing of telling Pelicans now, Rich Paul tells ESPN: "Anthony wanted to be honest and clear with his intentions and that's the reason for informing them of this decision now. That's in the best interests of both Anthony's and the organization's future." twitter.com/wojespn/statu…
πŸ‘︎ 53
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/rickydcm
πŸ“…︎ Jan 28 2019
🚨︎ report
I wake up with the best intentions everyday

Everyday my breakfast is calculated and void of any triggers. But as the day progresses I find a way to fail. Every day I start my day off right, but I always fall off the wagon

πŸ‘︎ 8
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/SpecialUnitt
πŸ“…︎ May 24 2019
🚨︎ report
What is the best response to, β€œ What are your intentions with my daughter?”
πŸ‘︎ 2
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/KingBeaner23
πŸ“…︎ Jul 14 2019
🚨︎ report
What is something you did with the best of intentions that went completely wrong?
πŸ‘︎ 5
πŸ’¬︎
πŸ‘€︎ u/kingbendo
πŸ“…︎ Sep 21 2019
🚨︎ report

Please note that this site uses cookies to personalise content and adverts, to provide social media features, and to analyse web traffic. Click here for more information.