How close to collapse was the french army during the 1917 mutinies? How aware of the french situation were all the belligerants?
The Étaples Mutiny was a series of mutinies that began on this day in 1917, committed by British Army and Imperial soldiers in the Northern French coastal port of Étaples during World War I.
What if the 1917 French Army mutinies escalated into a communist revolution?
It's been 100 years since the French Army mutinies of 1917, when will the classified files of the event be released to the public and where can I find them?
What if right at the beginning of operation Michael a mass mutiny occurred within both the French and British Armies
Right as operation Michael begins hundreds of thousand of French and more hundreds of thousands of British desert and more walk out of the trenches hands up in a surrender.
1917 French Army mutinies in a nutshell
Without the aid of American troops, the French army would've continued to mutiny and the war would've been lost
Does any one have any good primary sources of the 1917 French Army Mutiny?
Really struggling to find primary sources in English for this event if any one can point me in the right direction it would be greatly appreciated.
[May 27th, 1917] French Army desertions turned to mutiny as up to 30,000 soldiers left the front line and reserve trenches and returned to the rear.
ww2-weapons.com/diary-may…
What is G.J. Meyer talking about? What information about the 1917 French Army mutinies will be unsealed in 2017 by the French government?
In G.J. Meyer's "A World Undone" there is a passage regarding the mutinies of French troops in 1917:
"Troops were crowding into Paris in a state of extreme disorder. French archives on the mutiny have been sealed since the war and will remain so until 2017, but enough is known to make clear that at its peak it was a threat to the survival of the republic."
What information will be unsealed? When this year will it be unsealed?
[High Crimes and History] The Breaking Point - WWI French Army Mutinies
Episode Link
[True Crime, History] High Crimes and History | The Breaking Point - WWI French Army Mutinies
iTunes // Stitcher // Google Play // Spotify // Website //
Every person's will has a breaking point. But what happens when it's not one man, but a whole army? In 1917 the French army had reached the limit of their morale. Ordered into the trenches, entire units mutinied, and the fate of the war suddenly hinged on the relationship between commander and recruit. The result almost cost the Allies the war.
Most true crime covers the past hundred years of recorded history. We cover the rest of it. From murderous knights and pirate kings to ancient Chinese forensic investigators and the Renaissance's literal fashion police, our episodic podcast dives deep into the historical characters and events that make up some of the greatest crimes the world has ever seen — and certainly not found in your textbooks.
Facebook // Instagram // Twitter
Has the recent declassification of the records of the french army mutinies of WW1 shed any new light on the events?
The mutinies started the 27th of may 1917 and the records were supposed to be classified for 100 years. I haven't been able to find anythinig online that deals with these new sources. Can any historian share some new insights or haven't the sources been declassified yet?
What have we learned from newly released documents about the French army mutiny in 1917?
In The World Undone G. J. Meyer mentions that records of the mutiny would be released in 2017. Did this happen? What did we learn from them?
How serious were the mutinies and morale problem in the French army during WWI? How did it start and what was actually going on in those units that did mutiny? How did the higher ups go about stopping it?
How widespread were the French Army Mutinies of 1917, and why didn't they cause the collapse of France like mutinies did in Germany?
Serving Jat governor From BJP threatening the PM of assassination and mutiny in Army by Sikhs and Jats. What a Clown Party 🤡
v.redd.it/ch8qflbvg4181
How serious were the mutinies and morale problem in the French army during WWI? How did it start and what was actually going on in those units that did mutiny? How did the higher ups go about stopping it?
I've never seen the mutinies mentioned as much more than a footnote so I was hoping someone could shed some light on some of the finer details.
In particular I was wondering:
-How did it get started? Were there any leaders?
-How large did they get and what did they entail? Did it have any meaningful impact on the situation at the front?
-How did they get put down? Were there negotiations between high command and representatives from the men?
-Did anything like it happen in other armies?
-Any other interesting facts or good sources that could shed some light on the situation and/or its aftermath.
Thanks in advance for any answers, this has become by far my favorite subreddit to frequent.
On this day in 1918, members of the British West Indies Regiment began a four-day mutiny, facing pay and rank discrimination within the British Army. ~60 soldiers were tried for mutiny, and one was executed by firing squad.
Mutinies in the army. What army?
Mutiny in the army has caused (1-972) into a shit hole as the are now working with the LEGO’s against the green army
November 15th 1721. Philip Roche lead a bloody mutiny aboard a French ship and turned to piracy. "In November 1721 Roche and three associates booked passage on a French vessel sailing to Nantes. At a signal they rose up, slaughtered the French crew, and threw the captain overboard."
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phi…
Hannibal campaigned in Italy for fifteen years undefeated. We hear of no mutiny, revolt, or any conspiracy within his army. The Gauls were a huge asset of his, but perhaps did not expect the war to last so long.
Hamilcar Barca once said, “My son Hannibal will be a great general, because of all my soldiers he knows best how to obey.” Even as a general, Hannibal slept on a military cloak, eating the food of the common soldier and sharing their hardships. We never hear of a mutiny in his army.
A member of a Regional Intervention and Security Team (ERIS) of the French Penitenciary Administration. They are sent in if tensions arise (such as terrorism, hostage situation, mutiny or evasion). [1350×759]
Alternate history: Britain joins Imperial Germany against France. French volunteers (well paid and well respect by the Germans in comparison to the former French Generals as to prevent mutiny) defend the new German-French coast - Französische Landswehr Küstenschutz. Anime style :3!
reddit.com/gallery/pv0php
Hamilcar Barca once said, “My son Hannibal will be a great general, because of all my soldiers he knows best how to obey.” Even as a general, Hannibal slept on a military cloak, eating the food of the common soldier and sharing their hardships. We never hear of a mutiny in his army.
TIL “Decimation” was a form of punishment within the Roman Army in which every tenth man was executed by his fellow troops. It was used to punish offenses such as mutiny, desertion, and cowardice. The word “decimation” is derived from Latin meaning “removal of a tenth.”
militaryhistorynow.com/20…
Nexter testing the multispectral adaptive camo SALAMANDRE. Will be fitted on French Army vehicules.
v.redd.it/f19h3xgixha81
August 24th -- Ryan Grim: Pelosi Army Launching A Mutiny, PROVES Dems SCREWED Themselves Squashing Progressives
youtube.com/watch?v=R1Q_Q…
Last image of Zoulikha Echaïb, taken moments after her arrest by French troops on 10/15/1957 in the Algerian War. Tortured extensively, she died 10 days later after being thrown from a French Army helicopter while in handcuffs, her body not discovered until 1984 when a farmer found and buried her.
People in the army, what was something your superiors did that caused or almost caused a mutiny / rebellion.?
[1986] The Monocled Mutineer (Alan Bleasdale BBC) E01-A dramatisation of the life of Percy Toplis, one of the ringleaders of a mutiny in the British army which took place in Northern France at the height of the First World War.
ok.ru/video/1257918368354
USA/british/german/italian/french officers: we are equipped with pistols. Japanese army: s o r d g u n
This young man in Burkina Faso shot down a French army drone with his slingshot
2 December 1805 – War of the Third Coalition: French forces led by Napoleon Bonaparte decisively defeated a Russo-Austrian army commanded by Tsar Alexander I in the Battle of Austerlitz.
What do you call a recruit to the French army?
TIL that the US Navy refused help to the movie Crimson Tide by letting them film aboard Navy ships. They found the idea of a mutiny distasteful. So the French allowed use of their carrier Foch.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fre… Please note that this site uses cookies to personalise content and adverts, to provide social media features, and to analyse web traffic. Click here for more information.
